Moparts Tech ArchiveBig BlockBlowers or Blown InfoRoots blower guys, let's see your combos!DusterDave I'm interested in the whole combination, including rear gear ratio and converter stall speed if you run an automatic. What cam specs, carb size, brand and case size of blower, static compression ratio, piston brand, etc. ========================================= chrisf since nobody else is helping you out dave i will. Once you go a forced induction you wont want to go back to NA. DusterDave That's more gear and converter than I thought you had. The reason why I started this thread, is because I have an insurance settlement coming one of these days, and I always wanted to build a blower motor. I want to see and learn combos that work well for street/strip applications. ========================================= Streetwize Blowers can allow you to load the motor at much lower stalls, for a street driven car I wouldn't have a converter much beyond whatever your cruise RPM is at 60MPH. Too much stall with a blower can be detrimental 'cause it hits/slings the tranny with more inertia and can at best easily unload your tires or at worst break something in the drivetrain. On a 470 inch motor the way I'd set it up you'd have approx 650lb/ft below 3000rpm and the motor would pull past 7000. With that in mind, your combo looks pretty good, I'd use the long 7.100" eagle and put 75% of your port work into the Exhausts. On the street, I prefer smaller blowers turning faster than I do bigger ones turning slower, you don't really have enough motor in mind to fully utilize an 8-71 IMO, unless you're primarily going for image. Dual dominators are gonna be overkill with the E-heads (your exhaust is going to be your HP limiter) unless they're 750-850CFM. If it were mine I'd talk to Robert Landy @ DLI and run Their 250 Powercharger. I ran a smaller 174 powercharger on my same 12.30/111 shortblock Chris looks like he's got a great combo for a 383, but I'll bet his exhaust port is holding it back a little bit, a 440+ is gonna need more than a stock E-head port or the boost is gonna start backing up and heating up the blower at around 5000. I'm thinking about prototyping an intercooler and boost by-pass for the Roots , I've had a design sketched out for several years. Now that there's so many people building I/C cores and tubing, I'm gettingthe Jones to whip one up. My Daily Driver is a traction limited mid 13 sec. 2000 Si that is supercharged and runs 11 psi and still gets 31MPG. The unit is an eaton that spins 1.44 times the crank ans the motor routinely sees 8200RPM. With slicks and a limited slip unit it would go easy 12.80's. 255hp @ the crank from 1.6 litres is pretty d@mn good in my book. The one advantage to messing with these little imports is that it keeps me in touch with the latest technology, I'm died in the wool MoPar, but I also loved messing with Kaws, Suzukis and my old mid 11 sec. V-max. My dabbling with imports is more an extension of my enthusiasm for sport bikes that make viscious power. If I can help you set it up, lemme know! Wize ========================================== Wize. ========================================= Chris, I'll do some math, I've got some grind info I'll try to retrieve that might help you out. I think a 383-400 makes a great app for a blower.
========================================== DRAM Dave, i think wize has pretty much echoed what we already talked about on a couple issues. the 1050's for example (too much carb) and the heads neeing work on the exhaust mainly. i like the combo other than those items. i don't have a problem with the rod length at all though. i know if you think that duster runs good now, just wait... incidentally, i do like the idea of the gear change and a lower stall than what your currently using. the pure torque of that combo in a light car like yours will have no problem at all. your next investment will be some stickier tires LOL... ========================================= Thanks for the advice, Wize and DRAM. Lot's of good info to chew on. Well, I have a friend that wants to buy the Dominator. So, maybe a pair of Holley 850's instead. Do you think I should sell the Edelbrock heads and step up to 440-1's for the better breathing? Or keep the Eddies and max port the exhausts? ========================================== I am building a blown Hemi engine but only have the block right now. My buildup is Hemi mega block with 4.35" bore/4.15" stroke ported cast iron dual plug heads, 7.5 or 8:1 Aries pistons, BDS 871 blower with bird catcher electronic fuel injection. I am looking for 1000 Hp through a 4 speed and a Dana rear. I have wanted to build a blower engine since I was 15 and now at 39 I said what the f***. This will take a couple of years and about $30,000 for the engine but it is only money. Good luck with your project. Chris. ========================================= I am going to be the naysayer here. Obviously you like performance and want the car to be relatively quick while still streetable. My thoughts are, why handicap a potential high HP combo with E heads. Unload those things and put a head under the blower that will let it make some stones. While 440-1s would normaly not be my choice for a mild motor, in your case with forced induction they will be fine. That lung on top will push plenty of air through those big ports, so low speed port velocity will not be a concern. Some mildly worked -1s with INDYs blower manifold would be the ticket. ========================================== Dave, got to thinking. Why dont you just put a 250 shot nitrous system on it? You wouldnt have to change any of your existing parts and it would be cheaper than the blower as well. I know the visual image of a blower is cool,but as far as power goes I'd really look into a nitrous setup. Its cheaper, lighter weight, only provides power when you need it and can be used with the existing parts that you have. Not to mention, I bet you'd be more consistent with a nitrous system over a blower. As the blower heats up the air intake charge, you slow down. I know that with a properly sized blower, it wont heat up the air all the much. I've built several different combinations using Desktop Dyno and then ran them in the same car on Desktop Drag 2000. The nitrous engine was faster every time. Not sure if this is what you wanted to hear, but just giving my .02. ========================================== Keith W An old neighbor from TN just built his Blower Motor for his B bod. He put a standard 440 steel crank together. BDS 8-71, 2 750 mechanical Holleys on the top. He used a custom Isky blower cam. Venolia 7.5:1's. He had a set of Indy Steel heads and just used them for now.He bought a GER?? 2,500 converter with the 727 and 3.55 street gears in the Dana. He just got back from 10 chassis dyno pulls . The final pull made 700 HP and 750 Lb Tq roughly. I can get details from his buildup later.I forget what pullies he ended up with but it was 13 lbs of boost. ======================================== Well you know my thoughts. I have built a few blown engines myself. I pretty much echo what Monte said. Get some heads use the big blower and put some carb to it...I went 9'0s on a big blower mildly ported dual dominator car and drove it all the time...But what do I know.. =========================================== blowncuda, what heads did you use? I knew the Edelbrocks would be a bottleneck in the whole combination. But, keep in mind that I definitely want to keep my 2" Pro Parts headers. So, if I keep raising the power level like switching to better heads, the 2" headers become a restriction. ======================================== Monte and B-C make some good points, and if price is no object a set of -1 Indys will make more power and with the boost on demand, have no low-end laziness. I guess my point is with a well set up supercharger combo, even with the E-heads you already have, you're going to make more power than your possibly going to need, if you can't launch 700, 800 isn't going to do you much good. Your 2" pro parts will be fine, to fit Indys might be more $$$. DD's coming into some money but another $2500-3000 for all the peripherals would be hard for me to justify on top of the $$$ for the Blower. Build the block strong then tune the combo (Cam timing/carb)on the mild side and you'll still have all the power you want and run on pump gas; When you go to the track, add your slicks, change to a smaller snout pulley dump in some 110 octane and have at it. Best of both worlds, I think you'd be happier. Wize ========================================= When I started building mine , I talked quite a bit with Blowncuda. The only thing I didn't do was choose a cam he wanted me to. ======================================= Streetwize I think you'll have a great running combo. IMO the 8-71 as I said before is overkill but you can't beat it for curb appeal. As it is, providing you can hook, I think you could run 10.70's @ 126 with about 10 pounds of boost. The compressed air's gonna run out of places to go above ~5000 rpm so your boost in the manifold will rise but the power will stop going up. It will run great but I don't think you have enough cam and head to get 10.30's. 6.5 lbs of intercooled air can make more power than ~10psi of non-intercooled, The blower is a heat-sink, keep it cool and running under vaccuum 80% of the time and your motor will make better power when you stomp it. I like higher static 8:-8.5:1 on most of my street combos. Wize ========================================= i've only built 50 or so blower combo's but only a couple of those were mild street combo's. the rest were all top alky mills. it just seems that there's a lot of good info spread around here and no one (including myself) has asked the magic question yet. Dave, how much streetable power are you looking for? is 750 HP enough? ========================================== Streetwize DD I think the cam converter 60 foot is where we gotta make the move to get high nines; I don't want to bet the farm on the exhauust alone. With an intercooler like I have devised, we could really move! Wize ======================================= To run the number you want,low 10's it is pretty much a no brainer combo for your car. Add boost...Its true big huffers are not very efficient. My partner and I's race car was originally a baby blower motor. It was equipped with a 177 Wieand supercharger,the car wieghed 3600 lbs and went 10.20's,so there is no doubt they can be made to run the number as well .I have built a few baby blower engines and they work great,heck the centrifigals are very stout pieces as well and are hands down more efficient. And they can be made to run killer HP numbers with a carb as well in a blow through set up. Just look at Filipowski's car running in T/A. his car is a blow though that runs 8.70's on a Drag radial at 3400lbs.. I ran 9.0's in the Cuda with a set of IRON heads. They were a left over set of Zeeker heads from my at the time race car. Basically a 440-1 in iron. They had minimal work done,just a good valve job and some minor exhaust work and bowl clean up. Like anything else it is a total combination that makes a package run the numbner. Not making needed changes(gear convertor etc)are just compromises that have to be overcome. BTW the intercooler idea is a very good one..Been a problem with the roots set ups all along. I would like to see what Wize has to address that issue. BDS offers one but most avoid it for a couple of reasons. One is that it is just too tall. And of course cost. I would rather have 10 lbs of good quality boost that 15lbs of poor boost. But what is a roots guy to do,there are not many alternatives. There is of course one very good one..NITROUS...Nothing like an intercooler in a bottle Not looking to piss in anyone's Cheerios here just sharing my experiences and thoughts. The exchange of info like this can only be a good thing in my opinion.. ========================================= What does fuel atomization look like comming out of an intercooled roots setup? The centrifugal guys like me are cooling air only and the carb atomizes as it's supposed to. Any idea of the effect of that type of setup? Just courious ========================================= lleuth, There are a couple obstacles, namely if the ambient inlet air is too cold the potential for frost or condensed water to build up is at least possible if insufficient heated air passes through the system. Another is the limited time the system can recirculate adequately chilled fluid, heat is constantly added to the process faster than it can practically be drawn away so eventually the fluid heats up and needs to be repleniished. Of course if a small refrigerent compressor system were belt or even blower pulley driven, this would not be a problem. The A/C compressor would not have to be very large and could possibly be driven off one of the rotors from an extended shaft/coupling on the back of the blower. On a wet carbureted system you won't be able to keep the fuel in suspension if passed through an intercooler, aditionally the friction losses would be horrendous. Couple that to the fact you would be pumping a hot flamable mixture around the engine compartment and you see that design is not practical. It works perfectly well in a direct port injected system because only air is moving from the compressor through the intercooler. Blower cases could also be designed with surface cooling jackets either seperate or in series with the fluid intercooler as described above. The science and technology is well understood, even practical if you consider the potential efficiency gains. It's just who would fund the development? Oh well, back in the box I go! Wize ========================================= Wize ========================================== Good. I can hit 10 oh's and still keep my Pro Parts headers and Edelbrock heads. It'll be too much of an expense to switch to Indy's at this stage of the game. And, although not very efficient, I can get away with using a pair of 1050 Dominators. Sounds great, except some of you are making me a little concerned about the "hot blower" issue. I never drive my Duster for more than 30 miles at a stretch, and its usually during the evening hours. Would it still be a problem? ========================================= DD, In fact for what you're doing, there's not much point in going with a 470, 19 cubes aren't worth the expense and with the right blower set-up, you'll never miss them, we'll make them up with RPM on the big-end. But if you're going Mega block you get the 4.50" bore anyway, oh well more room for valves! The pro parts primaries are little longer (length)than you need for a blown motor but won't hurt ET much. There's no real practical way to shorten them due to where the slip ons join-up. I checked and Dwayne is getting 240-ish out of the exhaust port, I'd be tempted to run a slightly larger 1.84-ish exhaust valve. 240 will get us there with the right cam with HP to spare. When you get ready, if you want we'll talk to Scott about a Hydraulic roller that'll pull to about 6800. How tall are your tires on that beast, btw? Need to calc trap speed/gearing. I've got a 7600RPM solid grind that works VERY WELL but the spring pressure's a little rad for a streeter. IMO Phasing and lobe shape is every bit as much the key to Blower grinds as the grind itself. Wize BTW, Chris's motor in your ~400lb lighter car would probably get pretty close, 10-teens maybe. ========================================== Wize, yeah I would definitely want to get the exhaust ports opened up. A bigger exhaust valve is another possibility. The only reason I chose an 8-71 is because that's what BDS has listed in their blower kits for an RB motor. Since I'm a novice at this stuff, I'd prefer to buy a complete kit instead of having to piece it together. ========================================== Dave, It'd be tough for me to resist the temptation to "Supersize"- do a 2 stage plate/direct port N20 (intercooler on the BONUS PLAN)system, especially if you do a megablock! Wize ========================================== I decided to print out the E-mail between Chris and I regarding his blower tune, hopefully it may be of some related interest to the group: ----- Original Message ----- "Does your blower boost increase on the big end? E-mail me some specifics on your Cam timing LDA/Phasing etc. What are your 60 foots? I need some other Specifics such as header tubing size & length"
Your performance is very impressive, no doubt! You seem to have excellent drivability and your 60' are right there to where it would be tough to improve much. As for changing the cam, you might gain another tenth or two by adding another 10 degrees and .030-,040" lift to the cam, something like the Hughes 5663 solid cut on the same 112 centerline, you have enough stall to use it but IMO it's probably not worth all the hassle for very little overall gain. A better plan would be to work your E-heads to flow about 295i/-245e As for watching the gauges, let's keep your eyes on the road! lol. I'd recommend rigging a cam-corder securely in the car and the lens focused on your gauges, on your launch count off out loud "1-2-3-4-5-6-7-8-9-10", to give us a real-time "synch" so I can see your shift points and watch the boost. If you can cleanly focus the camera on the gauges as well as the tree/traps of course we wont need the "verbal". If your boost rises in a roots blower (especially at higher RPMs in high gear) it's a good indication that the air has no place to go and it's backing up/building pressure in the manifold. This means you either need more port or more cam. We know getting air "In" is not the problem. A simple calc says the exhaust porting is going to be your best bang for the buck, we can do the cam but again, we might have to re-examine the whole fuel curve, lets not throw out what's already a very good combination. The porting should increase your mph/top end charge and all else being equal, LOWER your boost in the manifold, which means MORE boost is making it in to the Cylinders. Worst case we may need to jet-up the carbs a little bit. Hope this helps, Bobby/Wize ========================================
Tech Index
|